Patch from Ralf Corsepius <corsepiu@@faw.uni-ulm.de>:

Yep, I have a bunch of bug-fixes and additions pending (Yet another monster
  patch, ... I can hear you scream :-).

  1) configure.in : one AC_CONFIG_HEADER(...) line too much.

  2) configure.in: gcc28 support is enabled by default, i.e. if no
  --enable-gcc28 option is passed on the command line. I am not sure if this
  is intentional.

  IMO, AC_ARG_ENABLE for --enable-gcc28 should look like:

  AC_ARG_ENABLE(gcc28, \
  [  --enable-gcc28                   enable use of gcc 2.8.x features], \
  [case "${enableval}" in
    yes) RTEMS_USE_GCC272=no ;;
    no) RTEMS_USE_GCC272=yes ;;
    *)  AC_MSG_ERROR(bad value ${enableval} for gcc-28 option) ;;
  esac],[RTEMS_USE_GCC272=yes])

  3) At the end of c/src/exec/score/cpu/m68k/m68k.h
  > #ifdef __cplusplus
  > }
  > #endif
  >
  > #endif /* !ASM */
  in my opinion these two statements should be swapped:
  > #endif /* !ASM */
  >
  > #ifdef __cplusplus
  > }
  > #endif

  I didn't try to compile for m68k, but does't this give an error? Is it
  compensated somewhere else - or didn't I look carefully enough?

  5) configure.in: --enable-cpp should probably be renamed to --enable-cxx, as
  gnu-programs use "cxx" to specify C++ specific configure options, while cpp
  is used for the preprocessor (e.g egcs uses --with-cxx-includedir, autoconf
  internally uses $CXX),

  6) The macro files from aclocal/*.m4 contain the buggy sed-rules formerly
  contained in aclocal..m4, i.e. the sed/sort-bug fix to aclocal.m4 didn't
  make it to aclocal/*.m4. I think I should feel guilty for that - Obviously I
  submitted the contents of an old aclocal-directory last time. - Sorry.

  7) For sh-rtems, we currently need to add additional managers to
  MANAGERS_REQUIRED (from inside of custom/*.cfg). Currently MANAGERS_REQUIRED
  is defined in make/compilers/*.cfg. This  seems to prevent overriding
  MANAGERS_REQUIRED from custom/*.cfg files - Obviously the files are included
  in such a way that the settings from compilers/*cfg always override settings
  from custom/*.cfg files.

  Furthermore, I think, defining MANAGERS_* inside gcc-<target>.cfg files is
  not correct - MANAGERS are not gcc-variant-dependent, but depend
  on targets/bsps and therefore should be defined in a bsp/target dependent
  file, e.g. in custom/*.cfg or target.cfg.in.

  I think defining default settings for MANAGERS* in custom/default.cfg could
  be an appropriate location. But this requires all custom/*.cfg files to
  include default.cfg, which *-posix.cfg files don't seem to do.

  Therefore I would like propose to move MANAGERS* to target.cfg.in - they are
  included by all custom/*.cfg files. Perhaps we/you should use this
  opportunity to merge parts from custom/default.cfg into target.cfg.in. This
  ensures to have the setting included once per target makefile and will open
  the opportunity to have autoconf doing additional work on
  bsp-configurations.



  Peanuts sofar, ... but here it comes ... (:-)

  8) I am preparing a major enhancement to autoconf support for
  gnutools/compilers. It is not yet finished, but usable and I'll therefore
  attach a preliminary version to this mail.

  Motivation:
  * Fix problems with --enable-gcc28, if target-cc is not gcc28 compatible
  * Fix -pipe problems
  * Fix problems with hard-coded paths in configuration files (esp. posix)
  * Fix consistency problems with explictly given gnutools and gcc's gnutools

  Currently included:
  * detection and checking of host and target compiler (gcc/g++)
  * checking if target gnutools are in path
  * checking if <target>-gcc -specs works (autodisabling gcc28 if not)
  * checking if <target>-gcc -pipe works

  Todo :
  * *posix.cfg files are not yet adapted => The hard-coded paths for these
  systems are still in use.
  * Check if the host compiler $CC is properly propagated to the Makefiles (I
  doubt it, but this should not matter)
  * Check if rtems' generic tools still work properly (It looks like, but who
  knows)
  * Integrate CXX support into default.cfg or gcc-target-default.cfg (It looks
  like C++ support is only used by posix BSPs)
  * Automatically handle RANLIB/MKLIB  for targets
  *  Plenty ...  (:-)

  Open problems:
  * Untested for non-gcc compatible host and target compilers. This  should be
  no problem if the tools are named follow gnutool's naming convention and are
  included in $PATH while running configure.
  * Intentionally using different tools than that gcc has been configured for,
  e.g. use a different assembler ? This should be still possible if
  XX_FOR_TARGET is hard-coded into custom/*.cfg. I don't see why anybody
  should want to do this, but who knows?

  I have tested this version on linux and solaris hosts, with gcc's
  directories mounted at weird non-standard mount points, using egcs
  (linux/sh-rtemscoff), gcc-2.7.2.2 using native tools (solaris), gcc-2.7.2.3
  w/ gnutools (solaris/linux). I don't expect it to break anything, but of
  cause I can't promise it. It will break most/all *-posix.cfg configuration
  almost for certain, but not more as rtems' current *posix.cfg configurations
  already do (hard-coded configurations).

  I am not sure if this is ready to be included into the next snapshot or not.
  Perhaps you might try this on your systems and if it you don't notice
  serious bugs you might put it into the snapshot for public testing (I don't
  like this, but I don't see another possiblity to test generality).

  I enclose a patch for configure.in and some configuration files which
  comprizes fixes for all items mentioned except of #3 . Don't forget to run
  "aclocal -I aclocal; autoconf;" after applying the patch (:-).
This commit is contained in:
Joel Sherrill
1998-02-17 14:09:30 +00:00
parent 81e0232b13
commit aa8a8c726b

View File

@@ -1,4 +1,5 @@
#
# $Id$
#
# Target specific settings.
#
@@ -10,15 +11,15 @@ CPPFLAGS = @CPPFLAGS@
DEFS = @DEFS@
LDFLAGS =
LIBS = @LIBS@
CC_FOR_BUILD = gcc
CC_FOR_BUILD = @CC@
CC_FOR_TARGET = @program_prefix@gcc
AS_FOR_TARGET = @program_prefix@as
AR_FOR_TARGET = @program_prefix@ar
NM_FOR_TARGET = @program_prefix@nm
LD_FOR_TARGET = @program_prefix@ld
SIZE_FOR_TARGET = @program_prefix@size
OBJCOPY_FOR_TARGET = @program_prefix@objcopy
CC_FOR_TARGET = @CC_FOR_TARGET@
AS_FOR_TARGET = @AS_FOR_TARGET@
AR_FOR_TARGET = @AR_FOR_TARGET@
NM_FOR_TARGET = @NM_FOR_TARGET@
LD_FOR_TARGET = @LD_FOR_TARGET@
SIZE_FOR_TARGET = @SIZE_FOR_TARGET@
OBJCOPY_FOR_TARGET = @OBJCOPY_FOR_TARGET@
CC= $(CC_FOR_TARGET)
AS= $(AS_FOR_TARGET)
@@ -28,6 +29,9 @@ AR= $(AR_FOR_TARGET)
SIZE= $(SIZE_FOR_TARGET)
OBJCOPY= $(OBJCOPY_FOR_TARGET)
CXX_FOR_TARGET = @CXX_FOR_TARGET@
CXX=$(CXX_FOR_TARGET)
export CC
export AS
export LD
@@ -51,3 +55,17 @@ XCFLAGS=$(CFLAGS_FOR_TARGET)
export RTEMS_BSP
export RTEMS_CUSTOM
export PROJECT_ROOT
# List (possibly empty) of required managers
# We require:
# region -- used by lib/libcsupport for malloc()
# ext -- used by libc for libc reentrancy hooks
MANAGERS_REQUIRED=region ext sem
# Create a RTEMS executable based on MANAGERS which was set in
# app's Makefile
MANAGERS_NOT_WANTED=$(filter-out $(MANAGERS), $(MANAGER_LIST))
MANAGERS_NOT_WANTED:=$(filter-out $(MANAGERS_REQUIRED), $(MANAGERS_NOT_WANTED))